Huang Yunling

The recent copyright dispute between singers Wang Sulong (汪苏泷) and Zhang Bichen (张碧晨) over the song Nian Lun (年轮) has reignited an older, more complex debate: allegations that the popular television soundtrack plagiarized the classic game theme Die Lian (蝶恋). This renewed scrutiny places two beloved musical pieces from different eras of Chinese entertainment under an uncomfortable spotlight, forcing fans and professionals alike to confront difficult questions about inspiration, originality, and the fine line between homage and theft in music composition. The controversy transcends a simple copyright clash, touching upon industry practices, legal definitions, and listener perception in the digital age. The Resurfaced Controversy Allegations that Nian Lun copied Die Lian are not new. First voiced in 2015 when Nian Lun served as the haunting insert song for the massively popular drama The Journey of Flower (花千骨), the claims initially gained little traction. However, the spotlight returned fiercely following the highly publicized dispute between Wang Sulong and Zhang Bichen regarding the official vocal rights to Nian Lun. This clash propelled the song back into trending topics, inadvertently dragging the old plagiarism accusations along with it. The catalyst for the renewed debate was a fan-made comparison video circulating online. This video…